FEATUREDAI HOT (Curated Pool)· aihot-apiZH00:00 · 09·14
→Amodei asked the industry to pace itself, but nobody defined the word
Amodei's September post called for pacing the frontier but never named a speed. Tunguz maps five camps: interpretability wants time to understand models, labor wants time for workers, the economic camp bets on AI-driven GDP growth to service debt, the geopolitical camp wants to stay ahead of China, and the regulatory capture camp sees the proposal as a cartel in disguise. All priced the consequences of a pause; none proposed a number. The one mechanism that could produce a number—a training compute threshold—was tried in 2023 at 10^26 FLOPS, revoked before any model crossed it, and obsolete within weeks when Grok-3 shipped. The post does not say whether Amodei responded to these critiques.
#Dario Amodei#Anthropic#Evan Hubinger
why featured
Featured · importance 78 · hook + knowledge + resonance
editor take
Amodei called for a pause, but after five camps weighed in, nobody named a speed. Tunguz points to the 2023 compute threshold that was obsolete before any model crossed it.
sharp
This is worth reading because Tunguz doesn't argue for or against a pause — he asks what "pacing" even means when nobody will name a number. He maps the five camps that responded to Amodei's September post: interpretability wants time to understand models, labor wants time for workers, the economic camp bets on AI-driven GDP growth to service debt, the geopolitical camp wants to stay ahead of China, and the regulatory capture camp calls the whole thing a cartel in disguise. Every camp priced the consequences. None proposed a speed.
The sharpest section is the closer: the one mechanism that could produce a number — a training compute threshold — was tried in 2023 at 10^26 FLOPS. It was revoked before any model crossed it. Grok-3 shipped weeks later, and roughly ten models will clear that bar this year. Training compute grows about 5x a year, so a fixed number is a ceiling the floor reaches on its own.
Tunguz doesn't hand out an answer, but he reframes the question from "should we slow down" to "who decides." The post doesn't say whether Amodei responded to any of this, which feels like a missing piece.
HKR breakdown
hook ✓knowledge ✓resonance ✓